Being involved in philanthropy can sometimes be challenging. If you’re looking to make a meaningful impact through donations or community involvement, it’s essential that you understand how nonprofit vs not for profit organizations compare.
Contributing to charity supports important causes and enriches donors’ lives by fostering a sense of purpose and community. It allows us to transform beliefs into action while making a broad impact. In fact, there are 1.3 million charitable nonprofits across America that heal, educate, and inspire people from all demographics.
Each type of organization has a vital role in society and can be more or less attached to a person’s interests, depending on the donor. This is due to the fact that they operate under different principles, structures, and purposes. Tax treatments, governance rules, and missions can also slightly change when talking about nonprofit vs not-for-profit organizations.
While both do not operate with the goal of generating profits for ownership, they differ from each other, among other reasons, mainly because nonprofits aim to advance a social cause and public good, while not-for-profits serve members’ goals. We’ll dive deeper into this in the next sections.
What’s a Nonprofit Organization and How Does It Work?
Some organizations focus on generating profit by selling a service to a customer base; their goal is basically making money. This is not the case for nonprofit organizations, which operate under a very different mission. So, what’s a nonprofit organization?
Nonprofit organizations are entities established to serve a public or mutual benefit instead of pursuing profits for owners or investors. Their core mission is to address social issues, provide public services, or promote certain causes, including education, healthcare, and more. Back in 2022, nonprofits comprised 5.6% of GDP and contributed $1.4 trillion to the economy.
Unlike for-profit businesses mentioned above, any surplus revenues generated by nonprofits are reinvested into the organization to continue with its mission rather than being distributed to shareholders. This reinvestment ensures that the organization’s goals and activities can be sustained and expanded over time, thereby increasing its impact.
One should note that while 501(c)(3) organizations are restricted in their political activities, they can engage in some lobbying as long as it is not a substantial part of their activities. They are prohibited from participating in any political campaign for or against political candidates. However, other types of nonprofits, like 501(c)(4) social welfare organizations and 527 political organizations, can engage more directly in political activities.
Each of these organizations share the essence of a specific cause commitment. Whether it’s fighting poverty, providing education, or protecting the environment, they channel all their resources towards achieving their mission. It’s their responsibility to ensure transparency and effectiveness through a structured approach to governance and financial management.
Among nonprofit organizations’ main purposes, you can find a general desire to provide public services, help others, or organize financial resources for a cause. While all three of them are related, we can divide them into three categories with some real-life organizations examples to better understand:
- Providing public services: Nonprofit organizations often help deliver essential services such as healthcare, education, and housing for underprivileged populations. When government programs can’t fill these gaps, organizations can make a difference. A good example is the Red Cross, which provides emergency response and disaster relief to social and economic crises.
- Advancing social causes: Many of these organizations focus on promoting social justice, equality and environmental sustainability. They work to address systemic issues and advocate for policy changes that benefit society in general. Organizations fighting for human rights like Amnesty International or environmental nonprofits like Greenpeace are practical examples of how nonprofit organizations can help advance social causes.
- Supporting community development: Nonprofits are especially important for their power to offer resources, support, and programs that enhance the quality of life for residents. Community foundations, like the Miami County Community Foundation, fund local initiatives that improve education, healthcare, and cultural activities. This quest to achieve a sense of community and shared purpose helps create bonded communities with higher opportunities.
Tax exemption in nonprofit organizations
Nonprofit organizations are not required to pay federal income taxes on the money they receive. This tax exemption allows more of their funds to go directly to their mission and programs. This status is granted under specific sections of the Internal Revenue Code, primarily Section 501(c)(3) for many charitable, religious, and educational organizations.
This tax exemption also incentivizes donations to be tax-deductible for the donors, providing the needed information and transparency. Organizations must comply with various regulations, restrictions, and requirements. The primary reason for tax exemption is to guarantee that the organization operates for the public good only.
The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) classifies nonprofit organizations into various categories based on their primary activities and purposes, with at least 32 different types. These classifications determine the specific requirements and benefits associated with tax-exempt status. However, most of them fall under the 501(c)(3) IRS tax-exemption. Here are four of the most common categories of nonprofit organizations:
- Charitable organizations: These are organized and operated for religious, charitable, scientific, public safety testing, literary, educational, or other specified purposes. They include a wide range of organizations such as hospitals, schools and shelters.
- Churches and religious organizations: Similar to other charitable organizations, this type of organization qualifies for exemption from federal income tax under Section 501(c)(3).
- Private foundations: These organizations typically have a single major source of funding (such as gifts from one family or corporation). Their primary activity is making grants to other charitable organizations and individuals rather than directly operating charitable programs.
- Political organizations: These are nonprofit organizations primarily engaged in political activities. Political organizations under section 527 are indeed tax-exempt, but their exemption differs from that of 501(c)(3) organizations. They are exempt from paying taxes on contributions received but must pay taxes on other income and follow different regulations regarding their political activities.
In addition to the above, other types of nonprofit organizations that classified under different sections of the IRS code, such as 501(c)(4) for social welfare organizations and 501(c)(6) for business leagues.
Although nonprofits enjoy tax exemptions, most must file Form 990, but exceptions exist. For example, churches and certain religious organizations are not required to file Form 990. Also, smaller organizations with gross receipts normally $50,000 or less may file Form 990-N (e-Postcard).
Financial management of nonprofit organizations
Effective financial management is essential to ensuring the sustainability and long-term health of a nonprofit organization. This outline of the financial goals and program expenses ensures stability through regular reporting to the board of directors. With that in mind, these are some of the required financial statements for nonprofits:
- Statement of financial position: what the organization owns and owes.
- Statement of activities: shows revenue and expenses over the year.
- Statement of cash flow: proves cash movement in and out of the organization.
- Statement of functional expenses: shows how funds are used within the organization.
Join us in shaping a better tomorrow for Miami County. Your support is more than just a donation. It’s an investment in our community.
What Is a Not for Profit Organization and How Does It Work?
Next, let’s examine what is a not-for-profit organization. Generally, nonprofits are organizations that qualify for tax-exempt status under the IRS code, particularly 501(c)(3), and focus on public benefits. Not-for-profits may include organizations that serve specific groups and may or may not seek the same level of tax-exempt status. However, both types typically reinvest surplus revenues into their missions rather than distributing profits to owners.
This helps start clearing the path of our nonprofit vs not-for-profit comparisons but is not the only distinction. Not-for-profit organizations do not earn profit for owners. Instead, the money earned or donated is reinvested into the organization to pursue the organization’s objectives and cover running costs.
Typically, these organizations are also tax-exempt and do not pay most taxes, and they can include organizations like hospitals, universities, national charities, and other foundations. They mostly look to achieve or aim to:
- Relieve poverty
- Advance education
- Advance religion
- Community benefit
Not-for-profit organizations, similar to nonprofit organizations, englobe a wide range of entities, each with unique characteristics. Common types of not-for-profit organizations are:
- Social advocacy organizations: These promote or lobby for a specific social cause or political effort. They fundraise through membership dues and public or corporate donations and are classified under 501(c)(4) for tax purposes.
- Trade organizations: These aim to improve business conditions for members and are funded by membership dues and fees for education programs. They can include chambers of commerce, real estate boards or health workers organizations.
- Foundations: Usually established by wealthy individuals or corporations to fund non-profits and events, foundations must donate a portion of their income to maintain status. They can be either private, established by individuals or corporations, or public, and receive money from various sources.
Legal structure and regulations
Not-for-profit organizations are usually structured as associations or cooperatives and must comply with state-specific regulations. Here are some key points to understand them:
- To achieve tax-exempt status, these organizations may request 501(c)(3) status from the IRS. However, they might also qualify under other sections of the IRS code, such as 501(c)(4) for social welfare organizations or 501(c)(6) for trade associations, depending on their purpose and activities.
- Not-for-profits with purposes that do not align with the criteria for 501(c)(3) status (charitable, religious, educational, etc.) may not qualify for tax exceptions. However, they may qualify under other sections of the IRS code, depending on their primary activities (e.g., 501(c)(4), 501(c)(6)).
- Not-for-profits must adhere to state laws governing their formation, operation, and dissolution, which can vary significantly by location.
- Not-for-profit organizations must remit payroll taxes on behalf of their employees. Therefore, employees and directors who receive income from the organization must report it to the IRS.
- Common problems include staffing issues, donor management, economic impacts, and organizational challenges.
It’s important that not-for-profit organizations follow these instructions while pursuing their social causes. This will ensure the continued success of the organization by maintaining a responsible and effective legal structure.
Financial management
Nonprofit organizations and not-for-profit organizations are often used interchangeably, but they can have different structures and purposes. However, the financial management principles generally apply to both types. Except for some small differences, let’s review them.
Revenue generation varies depending on the type of not-for-profit. For example, trade associations (501(c)(6)) and social clubs (501(c)(7)) often rely on membership dues and service charges, while many 501(c)(3) organizations depend heavily on donations and grants.
Effective budgeting is crucial in not-for-profits to ensure resources are allocated to meet member needs and support the organization’s mission. This involves detailed financial planning and monitoring.
Not-for-profit organizations must maintain accurate financial records and provide reports to members, ensuring transparency and accountability. This involves regular audits, clear financial reporting, and adherence to regulatory requirements.
Nonprofit vs Not for Profit: Key Differences
Understanding this nonprofit vs not-for-profit dynamic can be helpful if you’re looking to donate to an organization and make a meaningful impact through their contributions.
While nonprofit organizations are larger and more related to providing services to benefit the community at large, not-for-profits serve specific member interests, offering services, activities and programs tailored to their needs.
This table of key differences between nonprofit vs not-for-profit organizations sums up what we’ve been discussing so far:
| Aspect | Nonprofit | Not-for-profit |
| Mision and focus | Public benefit | Member interests |
| Revenue sources | Donations, grants | Membership fees, service charges |
| Tax status | Often 501(c)(3) tax-exempt | Can also apply for 501(c)(3) status if they meet the criteria. |
| Use of surplus funds | Reinvest into mission | Support member services |
| Examples | Miami County Community Foundation | Local chess club |
Overall, we could say that nonprofits tend to be larger organizations, which means they are required to maintain a higher level of governance and accountability, including regular financial reporting and adherence to specific regulatory standards.
Both types of organizations are vital to communities, offering different avenues for individuals to contribute to causes they care about. Your philanthropic vision can be more clear now that you understand the differences and similarities between nonprofit vs not-for-profit organizations.
Are you interested in learning more or contributing to our cause? Reach out with any questions you may have. With just one click, you can transform lives. Your donation has the power to create a significant change.